Paper ID:
Paper title:
Poor | Fair | Good | Very Good | Outstanding | |
Originality | |||||
Paper contribution (interestingness of the topics approached, scientific level) | |||||
Organisation of the subject matter | |||||
Language, grammar and style | |||||
Relevance to the scope of the journal |
Definitely Accept | Conditional Acceptance (with minor revisions) | Reject | |
Recommendation |
Comments/Suggested Revisions (please attach extra pages if required):
Name | ………………………………… |
Signature: | ………………….…………….. |
Date: | ……………….…….…………… |